The HRLocker Blog - HRLocker

How to Maximise Your HR Software Evaluation? - HRLocker

Written by Crystel Rynne | Dec 12, 2017 2:23:56 PM

Rolling out new HR software into a business can be a stressful decision for organisations of any size. Surprisingly, subscription cost is rarely an issue. But getting buy-in from senior management, as well as staff who will use the solution daily, is vital.

We deal with a lot of potential customers at various stages of their journey to the empowered freedom HR automation delivers. Many arrive frustrated after what should be quite a simple procedure has previously failed. Some come unprepared and make snap decisions. Quite a few waste valuable time when they have a solution on trial.

How to Find The Best HR System Solution for You

Choosing a supplier can become highly complicated – but it really needn’t be. First, you need to maximise your time spent testing systems out.

We advise you to:

  • Trial one system at a time, preferably with a live account, not a dummy instance.
  • Set up a small working group within the trial account with various permission levels.
  • Tick off the key processes you want to address most. Choose these wisely!
  • Confirm the reporting structure and usability are in line with your needs.
  • Deploy from a live trial account when you roll it out, roll it out from the top down, so leadership and admins invite managers in first. This ensures managers are familiar with the onboarding process and can then add and invite their teams.

Broadly speaking, we get two types of trialists signing up to test HRLocker. Neither of these is right or wrong. They’re just in different phases of their journey.

1. HR Software Solution – Just A Quick Look

These organisations are just looking at, or 'tire-kicking,' options from the market, so to speak. They decide to try a few at the same time. They don’t get set up in any system that well and are fielding constant sales calls from various providers.

These kinds of customers often struggle to get set up, which means they can’t test the processes. Judgements are typically then based on appearance alone. Later on, many start the process again as the required functionality doesn’t suit, mainly because a process wasn’t planned.

2. Making Well-informed Decisions

These organisations have taken a considered approach to implementing a solution that addresses their annual leave, timekeeping, training, recruitment, and compliance needs. They tend to write a 'wish list' and research providers that can deliver what they need.

They have a budget,  a project owner, and possibly a small working group that creates a shortlist and then sequentially – not simultaneously – trials the various options before making their preferred choice.

Budget is the Business’s Main Focus

The second type is a more measured approach. One of the most important factors is the budget. If you have a budget, it means you’re serious, that you have a considered plan to follow. But don’t worry. Budget often doesn’t, or shouldn’t, affect pricing, as many providers have transparent pricing terms.

The budget should also take into account the time and costs involved in selecting a solution. Having one isn’t about sending signals to hungry salespeople; it’s for your preparation. So, if you’ve got one, it’s because you mean business, have thought it all through and aren’t just guessing or window shopping with your own valuable time – and money.

It’s important to mention if you have a budget or not when you’re being asked about it. This is because providers’ sales teams want to give you the appropriate information and will be mindful of your particular timeline, giving you the focus you need when you want it.

They don’t want to hassle you, and they don’t want to leave you short either. They don’t want to overwhelm you with tonnes of info you don’t need or be too pushy, especially if you’re in the toe-dipping phase and just want a look around or get a brief overview. There could be something as simple as a short clip for that.

If you have a working group and a budget, the sales teams know you’re organised and serious. They can then deliver collateral appropriate to each level of the working group. This means they’ll spend a lot more time on getting you the right solution and package, regardless of spend.

For example, you might need specific info for your IT team, senior leaders, or finance department to address any concerns or questions they’ll have that might be different from those of an HR or office manager. Similarly, different sectors have different needs and focuses.

Just Testing The Water

The prospective clients that are just testing the water typically end up with slow or no progress. This is costly because the time spent can become considerable, creating a problem because the direction is unclear.

Often, many firms become frustrated with handling a project that’s going nowhere, and then shelve it to focus on primary goals, only to revisit it at a later date when the need suddenly becomes urgent. Sometimes the best decisions are not made in this last-minute environment.

As vendors, we’re delighted with quick, easy sales, so we have a bias on this. But fast sales don’t necessarily mean happy, long-term customers. We need our customers to make informed decisions, too. We’re not always the best fit. That said, even if you’re quite measured and focused with your time, you don’t need to make a meal of it.

A smaller business – or a cost-conscious organisation like a non-profit – can probably go with the first affordable provider they find that addresses 85% or more of their needs, as the extra time involved in the process below can simply be money wasted.

Here’s some advice to get the most out of that selection process, particularly for larger companies:

  • Build a small working group of around three key stakeholders and the project owner.
  • Set a budget, not just for your current headcount, but for the time spent on the project. Bear in mind a cost-per-employee to account for organisational growth too. Also, examine what you stand to lose if you don’t complete this project. Bear in mind the ROI a system can deliver to see what you’re leaving on the table if you don’t streamline these processes. Consider your broader compliance risks and related issues, and think about what having peace of mind is worth to you. We don’t like to sell on fear. Still, HR data that isn't secure, easily accountable for, and responsibly managed, for purposes like GDPR, can have quite a large cost in terms of risk, liabilities, and financial sanctions. Having a budget shows you’re serious and proves to yourself and your team that you’re organised and committed to seeing the project through to a successful conclusion for ongoing efficiency. 
  • Build a realistic requirements list. Unless you’re a large company, it’s unfeasible to put high emphasis on features that barely any provider delivers – especially if they don’t provide your core demands. You can distribute this as a request for information (RFI) document.
  • Set a timeline and rollout date. Build in all the trial periods you’ll need. See below why this is advisable.
  • Conduct research to identify solutions that meet your current and future needs as you scale. 
  • Line up a sequence of trials with each potential vendor that aligns with your timeline. Parallel trials rarely work out. Comparing solutions side-by-side may seem like a sensible approach, but it actually causes a lot of confusion. With a measured, sequential approach, you can compare them near the end of the process, which will enable you to have a better focus on each provider’s offering. There’s also less confusion without a handful of logins, which is particularly important in working groups where there’s a lot of time wasted finding access credentials and notes. You’ll be more efficient at handling the original raw data to input into each system, too, which will confirm to you more and more about what you want to automate in the process.
  • Carry out each trial in the same manner, addressing the key processes on your list. During these trials, set up your organisation and the working group team, sharing the permission levels to make a trial hierarchy within your working group. You’ll find trials ranging from a week to a month, so you need to optimise the time spent on each. Carry out your list of process testing and reporting to ensure the system can deliver on those functions, such as annual leave calculations and reports, recruitment metrics, and training needs analysis.
  • Record your results, tick your boxes and score each system.
  • Make a decision. Roll it out and enjoy the benefits the software provides. Something to consider is that at HRLocker, we only offer trials on live accounts, not dummies. So, you can take a lot of the work done in the setup through to deployment.
  • Set review periods after you’ve made a decision and selected your preferred provider. As you know, the business landscape is constantly evolving. So, be sure to regularly update your requirements list, score your provider against them, and ask if they have the features you might need in the coming year or so on their development roadmap. Request and record feedback from the entire team on how they feel about the system, then work with your provider to see if any issues are easily solved. Or put those requirements on your ongoing wish list.

We’re always happy to hear from anyone at any stage of their journey to deploying People Management Software. We’d be happy to hear about your situation and give our honest advice on what’s best for you.

It could be that we’re not a great fit for your needs, and we'll point you in another direction. Or that we recommend how to go about getting buy-in from your key decision-makers to ensure you get the project off the ground at a later date.

For example, sometimes we hear from office managers or HR admins who have been instructed to try a few systems and report back. Many times this fizzles out, and no progress is made.

Sometimes we hear from overly organised teams that are suffering from analysis paralysis. It’s all a balance.

No matter what your situation is, you’re guaranteed a realistic and honest conversation with us. We’ll always give our best advice on how to make your time spent count towards a successful outcome.

On Trial! How to Maximise Your HR Software Evaluation? was last modified: August 7th, 2025 by Agile Communications